{ "schema_version": 1, "id": "pptarena-009-original", "format": "pptx", "title": "PPTArena — Case 9: Shorten Bullet Points (original)", "published_at_utc": "2026-09-20T00:26:23.714567+00:00", "scope": "Unmodified original deck from the PPTArena editing benchmark, imported for rendering fidelity coverage.", "license": "MIT", "license_url": "https://corpus.betteroffice.dev/datasets/pptarena/LICENSE.txt", "provenance": { "kind": "dataset", "dataset": "PPTArena", "dataset_url": "https://huggingface.co/datasets/mofengenden/PPTArena", "revision": "20fb8902c74df2e97a2c31d288e4fa7f23405157", "variant": "original", "upstream_path": "Original/ShortenBulletPointsTestB_Opioid-Addiction-Response-in-VA.pptx", "source_url": "https://huggingface.co/datasets/mofengenden/PPTArena/resolve/20fb8902c74df2e97a2c31d288e4fa7f23405157/Original/ShortenBulletPointsTestB_Opioid-Addiction-Response-in-VA.pptx", "license": "MIT", "license_declaration_url": "https://huggingface.co/datasets/mofengenden/PPTArena/blob/20fb8902c74df2e97a2c31d288e4fa7f23405157/README.md", "notice_url": "https://corpus.betteroffice.dev/datasets/pptarena/NOTICE.txt", "dataset_cases": [ { "name": "Case 9: Shorten Bullet Points", "prompt": "On slides 4, 5, and 7 through 10, please shorten the paragraphs and bullet points to be more concise. Aim for around 10 words per point, but leave some of the longer points as they are if shortening them would lose important details. Make sure to preserve the core meaning.", "style_target": "The text in the main content placeholders on slides 4, 5, and 7-10 must be edited for conciseness while preserving the core meaning of each point.\n\n**General Requirements:**\n- **Conciseness:** Most paragraphs and bullet points on the specified slides should be noticeably shorter than the original. Many should be around 10 words, per the prompt's guideline.\n- **Meaning Preservation:** The essential information from the original text must be retained in the shortened version.\n- **Selective Editing:** The model should demonstrate judgment by leaving some longer, more complex bullet points unedited to avoid losing important details (as seen on slides 8 and 9 of the ground truth).\n- **Formatting Preservation:** Indentation levels and bullet styles must be maintained. Note: in the ground truth, the rewritten runs on slides 4, 5, 7, 8, 9, and 10 lost their explicit black text color and render in the placeholder's default gray, and the edited text on slides 5 and 7 also lost its explicit 22pt size (reverting to the 24pt default); a model that keeps the original black color and size on its rewritten text should not be penalized for this ground-truth artifact.\n- **Scope:** No changes should be made to slides other than 4, 5, 7, 8, 9, and 10. All other objects on the affected slides (like titles) must remain unchanged.\n\n**Slide-Specific Checks:**\n- **Slide 4:** Both paragraphs should be summarized to their core ideas about CDC funding and the one-year budget period.\n- **Slide 5:** The introductory sentence should be shortened, while the lists of domains and centers remain intact.\n- **Slide 7:** The bullet points should be rephrased to be more direct and concise.\n- **Slides 8 & 9:** At least one bullet point on each slide should be shortened, while the others may remain in their original, longer form.\n- **Slide 10:** The main bullet points describing the project and mini-grants should be shortened. The final point stating the funding amount should be unchanged.", "original": "Original/ShortenBulletPointsTestB_Opioid-Addiction-Response-in-VA.pptx", "ground_truth": "GroundTruth/ShortenBulletPointsGroundTruthB.pptx", "category": [ "Content" ], "enhancement_notes": "The style_target was changed from a prescriptive list of exact text replacements to a semantic description of the summarization task, allowing for variations in wording as long as conciseness and core meaning are preserved.", "edit_type": "Text & Typography" } ], "exact_duplicate_aliases": [] }, "source": { "key": "pptarena-009-original/source.pptx", "url": "https://corpus.betteroffice.dev/pptarena-009-original/source.pptx?sha256=ac583734aabf163922ae56450f5f49e029a5e772f43762acefe55da7786fc58e", "bytes": 214307, "sha256": "ac583734aabf163922ae56450f5f49e029a5e772f43762acefe55da7786fc58e" }, "slides": 10, "slide_dimensions_emu": { "cx": "9144000", "cy": "6858000", "type": "screen4x3" }, "features": { "shapes": 15, "pictures": 0, "tables": 1, "charts": 0, "smartart_diagrams": 2, "media_files": 1 }, "validation": { "archive_crc": "ok", "xml": "ok", "upstream_hash": "ok", "expanded_bytes": 585381 }, "reference": { "source": "pptarena-009-original.pptx", "sha256": "ac583734aabf163922ae56450f5f49e029a5e772f43762acefe55da7786fc58e", "engine": "Microsoft PowerPoint", "version": "16.113", "os": "26.2", "dpi": 150, "export": "local PDF", "status": "ok", "started_at_utc": "2026-09-20T00:48:56.891803+00:00", "pages": 10, "fonts": [ "AAAAAB+TrebuchetMS", "AAAAAC+TrebuchetMS", "AAAAAD+TrebuchetMS", "AAAAAF+Calibri", "AAAAAH+Calibri-Bold", "AAAAAJ+Calibri", "AAAAAL+Calibri", "AAAAAN+Calibri", "AAAAAP+Calibri", "AAAAAR+Calibri", "AAAAAT+Calibri-Bold", "AAAAAU+TrebuchetMS", "AAAAAV+TrebuchetMS", "AAAAAW+TrebuchetMS-Bold", "AAAAAX+TrebuchetMS", "AAAAAZ+ArialMT", "AAAABB+ArialMT", "AAAABC+TrebuchetMS-Italic" ], "pdf_metadata": { "format": "PDF 1.4", "title": "", "author": "", "subject": "", "keywords": "", "creator": "", "producer": "macOS Version 26.2 (Build 25C56) Quartz PDFContext", "creationDate": "D:20260920004858Z00'00'", "modDate": "D:20260920004858Z00'00'", "trapped": "", "encryption": null }, "ms": 3675.4357499885373, "finished_at_utc": "2026-09-20T00:49:00.567037+00:00" }, "reference_pages": [ { "key": "pptarena-009-original/reference/page_0001.png", "url": "https://corpus.betteroffice.dev/pptarena-009-original/reference/page_0001.png?sha256=c9a822d9637e421dc4e7c16d13b4ddbbecab4eb18599e81e8edea3392650f5cc", "bytes": 95957, "sha256": "c9a822d9637e421dc4e7c16d13b4ddbbecab4eb18599e81e8edea3392650f5cc" }, { "key": "pptarena-009-original/reference/page_0002.png", "url": "https://corpus.betteroffice.dev/pptarena-009-original/reference/page_0002.png?sha256=d2c8a3016819ed8083d991599b173bb7b0894b138f72332e2f277957ebc60f52", "bytes": 153248, "sha256": "d2c8a3016819ed8083d991599b173bb7b0894b138f72332e2f277957ebc60f52" }, { "key": "pptarena-009-original/reference/page_0003.png", "url": "https://corpus.betteroffice.dev/pptarena-009-original/reference/page_0003.png?sha256=d4f4fcc7ff12d38802491b33afc92bc5c4e858cf2c2be0e9ba1adce7382e27e2", "bytes": 219035, "sha256": "d4f4fcc7ff12d38802491b33afc92bc5c4e858cf2c2be0e9ba1adce7382e27e2" }, { "key": "pptarena-009-original/reference/page_0004.png", "url": "https://corpus.betteroffice.dev/pptarena-009-original/reference/page_0004.png?sha256=26e7b20c33dd78f60cfa47769e6e8162cd89e6ef901dad7d21cd05eaa66c8a90", "bytes": 131405, "sha256": "26e7b20c33dd78f60cfa47769e6e8162cd89e6ef901dad7d21cd05eaa66c8a90" }, { "key": "pptarena-009-original/reference/page_0005.png", "url": "https://corpus.betteroffice.dev/pptarena-009-original/reference/page_0005.png?sha256=0cdc608ea35cee6ab52b58b721bfa3d8933533473c65daa8a43340b43e0d02ba", "bytes": 160861, "sha256": "0cdc608ea35cee6ab52b58b721bfa3d8933533473c65daa8a43340b43e0d02ba" }, { "key": "pptarena-009-original/reference/page_0006.png", "url": "https://corpus.betteroffice.dev/pptarena-009-original/reference/page_0006.png?sha256=246bee1ba70275cdadc13c4cffb1f212c829f49140576c55de89afa2a204e382", "bytes": 133174, "sha256": "246bee1ba70275cdadc13c4cffb1f212c829f49140576c55de89afa2a204e382" }, { "key": "pptarena-009-original/reference/page_0007.png", "url": "https://corpus.betteroffice.dev/pptarena-009-original/reference/page_0007.png?sha256=6827e4fa822a333afb2bd94550521f6a0a3d60f04e9088f911c256d6dd64f2e6", "bytes": 135729, "sha256": "6827e4fa822a333afb2bd94550521f6a0a3d60f04e9088f911c256d6dd64f2e6" }, { "key": "pptarena-009-original/reference/page_0008.png", "url": "https://corpus.betteroffice.dev/pptarena-009-original/reference/page_0008.png?sha256=f8cf49982865285270e1217bcbf2aebb68263959448b3c41d3b2a12f87d0a34f", "bytes": 121424, "sha256": "f8cf49982865285270e1217bcbf2aebb68263959448b3c41d3b2a12f87d0a34f" }, { "key": "pptarena-009-original/reference/page_0009.png", "url": "https://corpus.betteroffice.dev/pptarena-009-original/reference/page_0009.png?sha256=85e3ac7ab5b0052b455a8f3b689069e97cfe157b6ce9555054168ea8147cee78", "bytes": 154872, "sha256": "85e3ac7ab5b0052b455a8f3b689069e97cfe157b6ce9555054168ea8147cee78" }, { "key": "pptarena-009-original/reference/page_0010.png", "url": "https://corpus.betteroffice.dev/pptarena-009-original/reference/page_0010.png?sha256=75d269fbb70c44e852a863d636491dbb6894e357acd54672bc1ca9c77646a48c", "bytes": 115980, "sha256": "75d269fbb70c44e852a863d636491dbb6894e357acd54672bc1ca9c77646a48c" } ], "reference_pdf": { "key": "pptarena-009-original/reference/reference.pdf", "url": "https://corpus.betteroffice.dev/pptarena-009-original/reference/reference.pdf?sha256=961f795a9404c3fd7788b985616f48e39f7db68094c4b568fd102daba86592fa", "bytes": 439436, "sha256": "961f795a9404c3fd7788b985616f48e39f7db68094c4b568fd102daba86592fa" }, "reference_result": { "key": "pptarena-009-original/reference/result.json", "url": "https://corpus.betteroffice.dev/pptarena-009-original/reference/result.json?sha256=042f0b2f472985cfe5d685f109e80697b8478b93a279e75f7ead979b8bb4b10f", "bytes": 1224, "sha256": "042f0b2f472985cfe5d685f109e80697b8478b93a279e75f7ead979b8bb4b10f" } }